Three years ago today my father died, one week short of his 89th birthday. He's been on my mind a lot lately, mainly because I recently read all three volumes of O.E. Rolvaag's trilogy about Norwegian immigrants, Giants in the Earth, Peder Victorious and Their Father's God.
Rolvaag's books were set in the 1870s in the territory that eventually became South Dakota . My father and his family came from Norway to Washington State in 1922. But on many levels, those were the only two differences between the families of Rolvaag's protagonist Peder Holm and mine.
A home movie was made of my parents' wedding in 1942, something unusual for the time. Part of it is shot inside the Catholic church in Ellensburg, Washington, and part of it is shot at the ranch my mother's family had since shortly after they crossed the Oregon Trail in 1857.
In the film -- which has now been transferred to video -- I can see my mother as a radiant, clearly virginal young bride, my maternal grandmother as warm and bosomy-looking as I remember her, and my dad in a rather dreadful Brylcreamed haircut, looking young, awkward, and scared.
I've always known that one of the big issues in my parents' marriage was the fact that my very Catholic mother married a Protestant, and thought this was so fraught because my maternal grandparents could barely endure a mixed marriage. But then I looked carefully at the part of the film shows my dad's side of the family inside the church and saw the other side of the equation. They were Evangelical Lutherans from a very pietistic sect, and they are looking wary and anxious as if they expected Satan himself to leap out at them from behind one of the popish statues in the church.
In other words, one of the chief realities of my parents' marriage was that it was a battleground in which the wars of religion were fought over and over and over again. My pious mother was a product of the brand of Catholicism that truly believed there was no salvation outside the Church. Her single-minded aim was to get Dad to convert to Catholicism, no matter what the stakes.
Dad came from a sect for which the Reformation was still very much alive and well. And I think, after reading Rolvaag's novels, I can begin to understand that probably he and the rest of his family had their religious commitment entwined with their desire not to lose their Norwegian culture. And there was no greater anathema for them than the Catholic church.
When they emigrated to Washington State from Selbu, Norway, my father's family and others from their same small town started their own Selbu Lutheran church in the middle of the wheat fields of Washington State's Whitman County. Dad, who was the youngest in his family, was in the last class that was confirmed there in the Norwegian language. For years the services were conducted in Norwegian. And people who were members of this particular Lutheran sect didn't drink, dance or play cards. My mother's family did all three.
Because of the promises Dad had to sign in order to marry 'Mom, we were raised Catholic, in the triumphalistic Catholic church of the American 1950s. We knew we were members of the one true church and that we were to have nothing to do with any other. We never missed Mass, all of us were enrolled in Catholic schools, and Mom could never forgo an opportunity for us to do all the extra devotional things like making the novena to St. Francis Xavier, and getting our throats blessed every February 3 on the Feast of St. Blaise. (Yes, we really did that).
My parents separated when I was in 4th grade and lived apart until the end of my 8th grade year. Dad was drinking, seeing other women, and when he did come home, was either knocking our mom or one of us around. Yet every night we were required to kneel around Mom's bed to say the rosary so that Dad would become a Catholic and come back home to live with us again. That's right, please dear God make our wife-beating alcoholic unfaithful father come back home again. Talk about cognitive dissonance! Prayer was not a connection to the sacred, but, for me, at least, a guilt-ridden petition for something I truly didn't want.
Eventually Dad did convert, was baptized a Catholic, and did come home to stay. My mother was ecstatic. But nothing really changed. We still went to mass every Sunday and hit all the other novenas and devotionals at church. Dad seldom came as he was always out at Boeing nearly every weekend, doing some kind of important defense work or because he was needed by the space program. When he did surface, it was often after he'd stopped by a bar on the way home with his Boeing and Air Force buddies.
He'd snarl because dinner was overcooked -- to the end of my days I'll always hear him say ``you killed the meat, Mary. You killed the God damned meat'' -- and became even more of a martinet about table manners. Even now I can't eat a meal unless my left hand is in my lap, and whenever I cut butter from the cube of butter, it has to be cut absolutely square. Dad's punishment for us when we misbehaved at the table was to force us to read the Bible, not a practice that filled us with the love of scripture.
I think Dad caught the words, but not the tune of Catholicism, and he viewed religion and religious practice through the filter of his Lutheran upbringing. When he was old and frail and clearly dying, he was terrified of death, mainly, I think, because he envisioned he was going to end up in the worst hell of Martin Luther's imaginings.
Mom died 35 years before Dad. She had cancer of many kinds that put her through at least two agonizing years. Just as she did with my father's abuse, she saw the sufferings of her illness as some task God laid before her that she must endure out of her religious devotion.
There's an expression commonly used in Catholicism, ``offer it up for the poor souls in Purgatory.'' The idea is that one endures misery or discomfort for the sake of those poor souls that haven't yet made it to heaven, but who are doing penance in Purgatory for their sins on earth. Mom offered it all up for the poor souls in purgatory.
Many times each of us begged her to get a divorce and start a new life, freeing her from Dad's endless cycle of drinking and abuse. She would have none of it because ``I made a solemn vow before God and this is what He asks of me.'' And I will always remember hearing her weep in the hospital when her beautiful long blond hair fell out after her radiation treatment. I can hear her saying ``I gave You everything else. Why are You asking this of me, too?'' But she offered it up, as she did everything else.
The last book in Rolvaag's trilogy deals with the marriage of Norwegian immigrant Lutheran Peder Holm to Susie Doheny, an Irish Catholic. This marriage was as doomed as my parents' and, for the most part, doomed for the same reasons. Their only child is secretly baptised -- at two different times -- a Lutheran and a Catholic. Susie cannot fathom that there is any good in Lutheranism, and Peder despises the priest and all the trappings of Catholicism -- a rosary, a picture of Mary -- that Susie has brought into the house.
Each character is so stiff-necked as to be incapable of tolerating, let along embracing, any divergent point of view. Each views the other's religion with fear and contempt. And for each of them, religion becomes the defining metaphor. Peder is not as firmly connected to his church as Susie is to hers, but his mother, with whom they live, is nothing short of fanatical. And eventually Peder becomes infected with her intolerance, too.
I wonder what happened to that fictional child of Susie and Peder? What did he become when he grew up? I wonder if he was like me and my siblings? I think it's no accident that none of my parents' four children practices the religion of either parent.
I had to make a change. It took a long while for me to figure out where I wanted to go and then, how to get there. But now, when people discover I'm a Pagan, and ask me what my religious life is all about, I generally say I'm dancing with the Goddess. What do I mean by this?
I'm not offering things up for the poor souls. I'm not worrying about hell of any kind. I live by an ethical system that emphasizes the here and now, not the pie in the sky, or the punishment down below. I see the earth as sacred and dance my way through the turning of the wheel of the seasons. I can stand in a circle shoulder to shoulder with Celtic reconstrucionists or Wiccans or Heathens for a ritual and not be undone by differences in pantheons or vocabularies. I go to sleep at night in a room where a large fierce image of Kali Ma wearing a necklace of human skulls is on one wall, and a gentle-looking Kwan Yin pouring out the waters of compassion is on another. When I knead bread dough, dump food scraps into my compost bin, push sunflower seeds into the soil or set my sewing machine whirring its way across yards of fabric, I know absolutely that I am a priestess of the Goddess and that I am performing sacred acts.
My world is now many miles from the worlds of Peder Holm and Susie Doheny, and, I hope, from the religious strife that was so entwined with my parents' lives, and so powerfully affected their children. It may not be the world that any of my siblings or children would choose. But it's a place where I can breathe freely, find joy, and yes, dance, even considering my crappy creaky crone knees. Would that either or both of my parents could ever have found such a place!
I'm not saying that my place is better than either my mother's or my father's. But I do know that it works for me. And that I'll never try to inflict it on any of my children or others in my family. I already know that down side way too well.